Resource Navigator

Role

Product Designer,
UX Research Lead

Timeline

7 months

Tools

Figma, Figjam, Qualtrics,
Google Survey

Team

5 UX Designers/Researchers

Context

📝 Overview

The Mentoring Partnership (TMP), a non-profit offering training and educational content for youth mentoring in Pittsburgh, engaged us to enhance their service ecosystem with emerging technology. Our redesign streamlined resource discovery by reducing search steps and improving users' understanding of TMP’s services.

👩🏾 My Role and Impact

As a UX research lead and product designer:

The Challenge

🧐 Users are confused about what services TMP offers, and do not often engage with the educational content on their website

User interviews with TMP's clients, local mentoring programs, revealed varying levels of awareness about TMP’s services, leading to low attendance at networking events. Clients also reported a "clunky" website experience, affecting sign-ups and engagement with educational content. Website data from google analytics confirmed low traffic to these educational resources.

As a result, TMP's valuable resources are underutilized, with users turning to Google and their networks for information and assistance instead.

Solution

Our solution is a redesigned web and mobile search experience for TMP’s website, making it easier for clients to find services, understand TMP’s offerings, and access relevant content for their mentoring programs.

1

Intuitive Search Bar

Query suggestions for faster browsing and comprehension of TMP's service offerings.

“Usually when I search, I’m not sure what exactly I need to type... but this feature of suggestion would be useful for me.” Usability Testing Participant

2

Comprehensive and Scannable Resource Results

A simplified filtering system optimized for discovery of new and relevant content.  

“It’s nice that it searches across the website, and I can get access to all resources at once.” Usability Testing Participant

3

Enhanced Resource Display

Highlighting key information for trust and credibility, and providing guided exploration.

“It shows TMP is a well rounded resource [library] for engaging activities and engaging mentors. This is really propelling TMP forward.” Usability Testing Participant

The Research behind the Solution

The client's initial project brief was to create new value for TMP's Service Ecosystem through identifying opportunities for improvement and leveraging emerging technology such as AI. Our overall process involved 2 phases: (1) Identifying opportunities to amplify TMP's value and (2) Increase the value + usability of the proposed solution.

Phase 1: Identify Opportunities to Amplify TMP's Value

👥 Programs seek educational and networking resources outside of TMP, unaware that they already exist at TMP.

At a national mentoring conference where we conducted contextual research, we found that mentoring professionals often seek cost-effective resources to enhance their mentoring practices. TMP provides such resources, so we assessed how well their services meet community needs through user interviews.

In 9 user interviews, 3 long-time clients discovered new services when we mentioned them and 7 described infrequent visits (2-5 x a year) to TMP's website -- despite googling and looking for educational resources weekly to support their mentors.

Additionally, responses to a survey of mentoring programs showed low awareness of their networking opportunities as well (7 out of 14 TMP clients).

🚩 Current search and filtering mechanisms do not support efficient keyword search, browsing, or discovery of resources

In user interviews, 4 out of 9 TMP clients also described difficulty with finding specific resources on the site, a seemingly small number but a big issue to dig deeper into. We conducted usability tests on the website and proposed targeting a redesign of the website based on the data we gathered.

📊 Evidence from Usability Testing 📊

  • On average, it took 3 min for users to find specific content on TMP's website using the current search and filtering mechanisms. (5 participants)
  • On average, participants gave the website a System Usability Score of 69, which is below average for websites in general.
  • Using the filtering system and website search bar garnered inaccurate or no results when specifically searching for resources.

Phase 2: Increase Value + Usability of our Proposed Service through Testing

💻 Redesigning TMP's website adheres to client constraints and aligns with users' mental models

We tested various search assistance solutions with mentoring programs and mentors. All 5 participants in round 1 appreciated advanced filtering and resource recommendations for content discovery.

Notably, 12 participants from round 1 and 2 preferred search assistance integrated into the website over AI tools or chatbots, as it felt more natural. Additionally, concerns about technical feasibility and user adoption emerged from the client, so we focused on high-impact ideas that users valued and that could be integrated with existing website services.

💪🏽 Increasing clarity and user control through reducing visual clutter and improving accessibility of prototype

In this stage, we conducted 3 rounds of testing with low to high-fidelity prototype flows in Figma and asked a total of 21 participants to perform tasks and evaluate the UI. We focused on making usability fixes such as creating simple, organized search interfaces to reduce feelings of being overwhelmed when browsing content. We also increased the font size to make viewing options more salient.

📊 Final Prototype Usability Testing Results 📊

  • On average, it took 2-3 clicks for users to find specific resources on TMP's website using our prototype. (9 participants)
  • "The prototype seems user friendly - Very easy and the resources look great." - Usability Testing Participant + TMP client
  • "I'm excited that there’s a broad range of content, I like seeing both trainings and resources." - Usability Testing Participant + TMP client
  • "This is really propelling TMP forward...making them more of a well-rounded resource." - Usability Testing Participant + TMP client
🗺️ Creating a feature roadmap with a phased approach through collaboration with technical stakeholders

We consulted with local technical solution architects and designers to develop a phased implementation plan with a detailed timeline for features and UI changes, which we handed off to TMP. I also prepared a client report with my team, outlining the research, UX recommendations, and solution details.

🚩 Challenges with Solution Direction
TMP was initially resistant to big changes in UI of the website, however our research persuaded them to pursue usability fixes and redesigning the website. This was an exercise in effectively communicating design decisions and product directions through research-backed arguments.

Project Outcomes

By leveraging human-centered(UX) research and design methods, our project had both short-term and long-term impacts on our client, TMP.

Some examples include:

  • 💻 Identified and addressed key website issues that caused drop-off and low traffic, leading to a more efficient and empowering resource exploration experience based on usability testing feedback.
  • 🧠 Helping TMP form a standardized way to understand their client base through archetypes and understand specific challenges for different clients.
  • 💰 Developing a practical solution that fits client constraints, including limited technical resources and maintenance staff, while leveraging existing services.
  • 📊 Identifying data collection opportunities to enhance understanding of client needs, engagement, and user experience for long-term strategic planning.
Next Case Study

SwiftPark: UX Design & Research